Picture this: you've spent years building your retirement savings in a Traditional or Roth IRA while working in the US. Now you're planning to move back to India, and suddenly you're hit with questions. Can you still contribute to your IRA? How will India tax your withdrawals? Do you need to cash out before leaving? One wrong move could cost you thousands in taxes and penalties.
For the 4.5 million NRIs in the United States, Individual Retirement Accounts remain both a crucial investment vehicle and a source of serious confusion. With 2025 bringing updated contribution limits ($7,000, or $8,000 if you're 50+) and ongoing changes to cross-border tax compliance rules, understanding how IRAs work for NRIs has never been more important. The stakes are high because IRAs face taxation in both countries, and without proper planning, you could end up paying taxes twice on the same money.
This complete guide will walk you through everything you need to know about managing your IRA as an NRI, from contribution eligibility to tax implications under the India-US Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement, and most importantly, what happens when you decide to move back to India.
Key Takeaway
Understanding IRAs can save you thousands in taxes and penalties when moving between the US and India.
Here's what you'll learn:
- When NRIs can and cannot contribute to IRAs after moving abroad or changing status
- How IRA withdrawals are taxed in both India and the US under DTAA provisions
- Critical forms like W-8BEN and Form 10EE you must file to avoid double taxation
- What happens to your IRA when you return to India permanently
- How IRAs compare to Indian retirement accounts like NPS, PPF, and EPF
What is an IRA and Why Does It Matter for NRIs?
An Individual Retirement Account (IRA) is a tax-advantaged investment account designed to help Americans save for retirement. Think of it as a container that holds your investments like stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and ETFs. The big advantage is that your money grows tax-deferred (or tax-free in the case of Roth IRAs), allowing your investments to compound faster than in regular taxable accounts.
For NRIs in the United States, IRAs serve as a critical pillar of retirement planning alongside employer-sponsored 401(k) plans. Whether you're planning to retire in the US, move back to India, or split time between both countries, understanding how your IRA fits into your overall financial picture is essential.
Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA: Key Differences
There are two main types of IRAs, and they work very differently when it comes to taxes.
Traditional IRA contributions are typically tax-deductible in the year you make them, reducing your current taxable income. Your money grows tax-deferred, meaning you don't pay taxes on gains until you withdraw. When you take distributions in retirement, the entire amount (contributions plus earnings) gets taxed as ordinary income. This makes Traditional IRAs attractive if you expect to be in a lower tax bracket during retirement than you are now.
Roth IRA contributions are made with after-tax dollars, so you don't get an immediate tax deduction. However, the payoff comes later. Your money grows tax-free, and qualified withdrawals in retirement are completely tax-free. To withdraw earnings without penalty, you must be at least 59½ years old and have held the account for at least five years. Roth IRAs are particularly attractive if you expect to be in a higher tax bracket in retirement or if you want tax diversification.
The choice between Traditional and Roth becomes more complex for NRIs because India doesn't always recognize the tax-free status of Roth IRA withdrawals. We'll explore this important distinction in detail later.
How IRAs Work for US-Based NRIs
If you're working in the US on an H-1B, L-1, or similar visa, or if you're a green card holder, you can open and contribute to an IRA just like any US citizen. You can have both a 401(k) through your employer and an IRA, maximizing your tax-advantaged retirement savings.
You can open an IRA through banks, brokerage firms like Fidelity, Vanguard, or Charles Schwab, or even robo-advisors. The account gives you control over your investment choices, and you can adjust your portfolio as your goals and risk tolerance change.
Many NRIs use IRAs as a supplement to their 401(k) or as a destination for 401(k) rollovers when changing jobs. The flexibility and investment options typically available in IRAs often exceed what's available in employer 401(k) plans.
2025 Contribution Limits and Recent Changes
For 2025, the IRA contribution limit is $7,000 per year for both Traditional and Roth IRAs combined. If you're 50 or older, you can make an additional $1,000 catch-up contribution, bringing your total to $8,000.
Recent changes under the Secure Act 2.0 have made IRAs even more attractive. Starting in 2025, individuals aged 60 to 63 can contribute an additional $10,000 annually in catch-up contributions to certain retirement accounts. The age restriction for Traditional IRA contributions has been eliminated, meaning you can now contribute at any age as long as you have earned income.
Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) for Traditional IRAs now start at age 73 (updated from 72), giving your money more time to grow tax-deferred. Roth IRAs still don't require RMDs during your lifetime, making them excellent estate planning tools.
For NRIs specifically, understanding these limits matters because contribution eligibility depends on having US earned income after certain exclusions and deductions, which we'll cover next.
Can NRIs Contribute to an IRA?
Understanding Eligibility
This is where things get tricky for NRIs. The short answer is maybe, and it depends entirely on your specific tax situation.
The IRS has one fundamental rule for IRA contributions: you must have earned income to contribute. But for NRIs and US citizens living abroad, the calculation of eligible earned income becomes more complex due to foreign income exclusions and tax credits.
The US Earned Income Requirement
To contribute to an IRA, you need US taxable compensation. This includes wages, salaries, tips, professional fees, bonuses, and other amounts received for providing personal services. Investment income like interest, dividends, or rental income doesn't count as earned income for IRA purposes.
Here's the catch: if you're living and working abroad, you might be using the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE) to reduce your US tax bill. While this is great for lowering your current taxes, it has a significant side effect on your IRA eligibility.
Impact of Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE) on IRA Contributions
The FEIE allows US citizens and green card holders working abroad to exclude up to $120,000 (for 2023, adjusted annually) of foreign earned income from US taxation. This is a powerful tax benefit, but there's a trade-off.
If you use the FEIE to exclude all of your income, you effectively have zero earned income for IRA purposes, making you ineligible to contribute. Let's look at an example:
Scenario 1: Priya works in Australia and earns $95,000. She uses the FEIE to exclude all $95,000 from US taxation. Because she has no income left after the exclusion, she cannot contribute to an IRA.
Scenario 2: Rajesh works in Singapore and earns $150,000. He uses the FEIE to exclude $120,000, leaving $30,000 of taxable income. Rajesh can contribute to an IRA because he has earned income remaining after the exclusion.
However, there's another option. Instead of using the FEIE, you can claim the Foreign Tax Credit (FTC). The FTC allows you to offset US taxes with foreign taxes already paid, but it doesn't reduce your earned income for IRA purposes.
Scenario 3: Priya (from Scenario 1) decides to use the Foreign Tax Credit instead of FEIE. Now her full $95,000 counts as earned income, making her eligible to contribute the maximum $7,000 to her IRA.
The key takeaway is that for NRIs living abroad, your IRA contribution eligibility depends on whether you have unexcluded earned income after applying the FEIE, or whether you choose to use the FTC instead.
Contribution Eligibility Flowchart for NRIs
Here's a simple decision framework:
Are you currently working in the US on a work visa or as a green card holder?
If yes, you can contribute to an IRA (subject to income limits for Roth IRA).
Have you moved abroad but still have US-sourced earned income?
If yes, you can contribute.
Are you working abroad and filing US taxes?
Check if you're using FEIE or FTC:
- Using FEIE and have income remaining after exclusion: You can contribute up to your remaining earned income or the annual limit, whichever is lower
- Using FEIE and excluded all income: You cannot contribute
- Using FTC instead: You can contribute (your full earned income counts)
Have you moved back to India and have no US earned income? You cannot make new contributions, but you can maintain your existing IRA.
The bottom line is that once you become an NRI without any US earned income (or with all income excluded through FEIE), you lose the ability to make new IRA contributions. However, your existing IRA remains yours, and you face no requirement to close it or withdraw funds.
What Happens to Your IRA When You Move to India?
One of the biggest concerns NRIs have is what happens to their carefully accumulated retirement savings when they decide to return to India. The good news is that you have options, and none of them require you to immediately cash out and face penalties.
Can You Keep Your IRA After Leaving the US?
Yes, absolutely. Your IRA doesn't disappear just because you're no longer a US resident. The IRS doesn't require you to close your account or withdraw funds when you leave the country. Your IRA continues to exist, and your investments continue to grow.
Most major financial institutions like Fidelity, Vanguard, Charles Schwab, and TD Ameritrade allow account holders to maintain IRAs even after moving abroad. However, policies vary by institution, and some may have restrictions on certain services for non-resident account holders.
The key things that change are your ability to make new contributions (as discussed above) and your compliance requirements for tax reporting in both countries.
Changing Your Address and Filing Form W-8BEN
When you move to India, you must update your address with your IRA custodian. This isn't just for receiving statements, it's crucial for proper tax withholding.
You'll need to submit Form W-8BEN (Certificate of Foreign Status of Beneficial Owner for United States Tax Withholding and Reporting) to your financial institution. This form certifies that you are a non-resident alien for US tax purposes and establishes your eligibility for any applicable tax treaty benefits under the India-US DTAA.
Without Form W-8BEN, your IRA custodian may withhold taxes at the default rate of 30% on certain distributions, even if treaty provisions would allow for a lower rate or exemption. The form is valid for three years from the date you sign it, so you'll need to update it periodically.
Important note: Form W-8BEN is not filed with the IRS. You submit it directly to your broker or financial institution, and they keep it on file.
Options: Leave It, Roll Over, or Withdraw
Once you've moved to India, you have three main options for your IRA:
Option 1: Leave it as is. This is often the simplest approach. Your IRA continues to grow tax-deferred (for Traditional) or tax-free (for Roth), and you can withdraw according to the normal rules when you reach retirement age. This strategy works well if you don't need the money immediately and want to maximize tax-deferred growth.
The downsides include having to stay informed about US tax law changes, maintaining communication with your financial institution from India, and dealing with potential complications around estate taxes if you hold significant US assets.
Option 2: Roll over to another IRA. If your current IRA provider doesn't support international clients or you want more flexibility, you can roll over your IRA to another custodian that better serves non-resident clients. The rollover itself isn't a taxable event if done correctly as a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer.
Some NRIs also consider rolling over a Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA (a Roth conversion). You'll pay taxes on the converted amount in the year of conversion, but future qualified withdrawals will be tax-free in the US. However, remember that India may not recognize this tax-free status, so consult with a cross-border tax advisor before executing this strategy.
Option 3: Withdraw. If you need the funds for a home purchase, children's education, or other significant expenses, you can withdraw from your IRA. However, this option comes with significant tax implications that we'll explore in detail in the next section.
The best option depends on your age, financial needs, tax situation in India (whether you're RNOR or ROR), and long-term retirement plans. If you're planning to eventually return to the US or split time between countries, leaving the IRA intact often makes the most sense.
How is Your IRA Taxed in India and the US?
This is where things get complex, and understanding the rules can save you thousands of dollars in taxes. When you're living in India with a US IRA, you're potentially subject to taxation in both countries. However, the India-US Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) provides relief mechanisms to prevent you from being taxed twice on the same income.
US Taxation on IRA Withdrawals for Non-Residents
From the US perspective, your IRA withdrawals are generally taxable regardless of where you live. The taxation depends on the type of IRA and when you withdraw.
Traditional IRA withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income at your marginal tax rate. If you withdraw before age 59½, you'll also face a 10% early withdrawal penalty unless you qualify for an exception (such as disability, first-time home purchase up to $10,000, or qualified higher education expenses).
When you take a distribution as a non-resident, the IRS typically requires a 30% withholding on the taxable portion. However, if you've properly filed Form W-8BEN, you may be able to reduce this withholding rate under the DTAA provisions. You'll still need to file Form 1040-NR (US Nonresident Alien Income Tax Return) to report the distribution and calculate your actual tax liability, potentially claiming a refund if excess tax was withheld.
Roth IRA qualified withdrawals are tax-free in the US, even for non-residents. A qualified distribution means you're over 59½ and have held the account for at least five years. However, as you'll see shortly, India may not honor this tax-free treatment.
Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) still apply to Traditional IRAs once you reach age 73. Even if you're living in India and don't need the money, you must take your RMD each year or face a hefty penalty (25% of the amount you should have withdrawn).
Indian Taxation: ROR vs RNOR Status
Understanding your residential status under Indian tax law is absolutely critical for determining how your IRA will be taxed. This is where many NRIs make costly mistakes.
Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident (RNOR) status is a transitional category that applies when you first return to India. You qualify as RNOR if you meet one of these conditions:
- You've been a non-resident in India for nine out of the ten preceding years, OR
- You've been in India for 729 days or fewer during the seven preceding years
RNOR status is powerful because your foreign income (including IRA distributions) is generally not taxable in India, as long as the income doesn't accrue or arise in India. This creates a valuable tax planning window, typically lasting 2-3 years after your return.
Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR) status kicks in once you no longer meet the RNOR criteria. At this point, your worldwide income becomes taxable in India, including your IRA withdrawals. This is when tax planning becomes crucial.
Let's look at a real example:
Amit returned to India in January 2023 after working in the US for 12 years. For FY 2023-24, he qualifies as RNOR.
If Amit withdraws $50,000 from his Traditional IRA during this year, this income is not taxable in India (though it remains taxable in the US). By FY 2025-26, Amit becomes ROR, and any IRA withdrawals from that point forward are taxable in India.
Understanding the India-US DTAA for IRAs
The Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement between India and the US prevents you from paying full taxes in both countries on the same income. The key provisions for IRA distributions fall under Article 20 (Private Pensions) and Article 23 (Other Income) of the treaty.
Under Article 20, private pensions and annuities are generally taxable only in the country of residence. However, the application to IRA distributions can be complex because the IRS may classify some distributions as "other income" rather than pensions, especially if you're taking lump sum withdrawals rather than periodic payments.
The DTAA provides two methods to avoid double taxation:
The Exemption Method: Income is exempt from tax in one country and taxed only in the other. This is rare for IRA distributions.
The Credit Method: You pay tax in both countries but claim a Foreign Tax Credit in your country of residence for taxes paid in the source country. This is the more common approach for IRA withdrawals.
If you're an ROR living in India and withdraw from your IRA, you'll typically:
- Pay US tax (with withholding at source)
- Report the income in your Indian ITR
- Claim a Foreign Tax Credit using Form 67 for the US taxes already paid
The exchange rate for converting foreign taxes to rupees is calculated using the SBI telegraphic transfer buying rate on the last day of the month preceding the month in which the tax was paid.
Here's a practical example of how this works:
Example: Deepa, an ROR in India, withdraws 80,000fromherTraditionalIRA.TheUSwithholds30). Her Indian tax liability on this income is ₹19.92 lakhs (assuming 30% tax rate). She claims a Foreign Tax Credit of ₹14.94 lakhs (US tax of $18,000 converted to rupees), leaving her with an additional Indian tax liability of ₹4.98 lakhs. Her total tax paid is ₹14.94 lakhs + ₹4.98 lakhs = ₹19.92 lakhs, eliminating double taxation.
Section 89A and Form 10EE: Your Key to Avoiding Double Taxation
This is one of the most important provisions for returning NRIs, yet it's frequently overlooked. Section 89A of the NRI Income Tax Act, introduced in 2021, provides critical relief for NRIs returning to India with foreign retirement accounts like IRAs.
Here's the problem Section 89A solves: Without this provision, once you become an ROR, India would tax the annual growth in your IRA (the accrued income) every year, even though you haven't withdrawn anything.
Meanwhile, the US taxes you only when you actually withdraw funds. This creates a timing mismatch that could result in paying taxes on the same income in different years, or facing liquidity issues (paying Indian tax on growth you can't access without incurring US penalties).
Section 89A allows you to defer taxation on your IRA until you actually withdraw funds, aligning Indian taxation with US taxation. To claim this benefit, you must file Form 10EE electronically in the first year you become an ROR in India.
Here's how it works:
- Year 1 (RNOR status): Your IRA grows from $500,000 to $550,000. No tax in India on this growth.
- Year 2 (First year as ROR): You must file Form 10EE to elect deferred taxation under Section 89A. If you file this form, India won't tax the $50,000 growth that occurred in Year 1, or any future growth, until you withdraw.
- Year 5: You withdraw $100,000. Both the US and India will tax this withdrawal in Year 5. You claim Foreign Tax Credit under DTAA to prevent double taxation.
Critical points about Form 10EE:
- Must be filed in the first year you become ROR
- The election is irrevocable, it applies to all subsequent years
- If you don't file Form 10EE, India will tax annual accruals on your IRA, creating the double taxation problem
- You need to provide details of your foreign retirement account, documentary evidence of how it's taxed in the foreign country, and reconciliation statements
Without Section 89A relief, you could face a situation where India taxes your IRA growth annually while the US taxes you on withdrawal, potentially resulting in tax on more than 100% of your actual gains when accounting for timing differences and exchange rate fluctuations.
The combination of DTAA benefits and Section 89A relief forms the foundation of tax-efficient IRA management for returning NRIs. However, navigating these provisions requires careful planning and documentation, which is why consulting with a cross-border tax specialist is highly recommended.
IRA Withdrawal Strategies When Living in India
Knowing when and how to withdraw from your IRA can make a significant difference in your tax bill and overall financial outcomes. The timing, amount, and method of withdrawal all have tax implications in both countries.
Before Age 59½: Penalties and Exceptions
If you withdraw from a Traditional IRA before reaching age 59½, you'll face a 10% early withdrawal penalty on top of regular income taxes. For NRIs living in India, this penalty can make early withdrawals particularly expensive.
Let's say you withdraw $50,000 at age 55. With 30% US withholding plus the 10% penalty, you'd lose $20,000 to the IRS, leaving you with $30,000.
If you're an ROR in India, you'd also owe Indian taxes on the $50,000 (though you can claim credit for US taxes paid under DTAA).
However, there are exceptions to the 10% penalty:
- Permanent disability
- Medical expenses exceeding 7.5% of your adjusted gross income
- First-time home purchase (up to $10,000 lifetime limit)
- Qualified higher education expenses
- Substantially equal periodic payments under IRS Rule 72(t)
For Roth IRAs, you can always withdraw your contributions (not earnings) tax-free and penalty-free at any age, since you already paid tax on that money. This makes Roth IRAs more flexible if you need emergency access to funds.
After Age 59½: Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)
Once you turn 73, you must start taking Required Minimum Distributions from your Traditional IRA each year. The amount is calculated based on your account balance and life expectancy using IRS tables.
For NRIs living in India, RMDs create a planning consideration. You're forced to recognize taxable income in both countries annually, even if you don't need the money. The silver lining is that these mandatory withdrawals are often smaller than lump sum withdrawals, potentially keeping you in lower tax brackets in both countries.
Roth IRAs have a significant advantage here because they don't require RMDs during your lifetime. Your money can continue growing tax-free (in the US) for as long as you live, making Roth IRAs excellent for estate planning if you want to leave assets to heirs.
Lump Sum vs Periodic Withdrawals: Tax Implications
The way you structure your withdrawals can significantly impact your tax burden, especially in India.
Lump sum withdrawals mean taking a large amount all at once. While this gives you immediate access to funds, it can push you into higher tax brackets in both countries. The India-US DTAA classifies lump sum distributions under Article 23 (Other Income), and they're taxable in both countries with credit available for foreign taxes paid.
Periodic withdrawals spread your distributions over multiple years, potentially keeping you in lower tax brackets each year. Under certain circumstances, regular periodic payments may qualify for more favorable treatment under Article 20 (Private Pensions) of the DTAA, though the IRS definition of "periodic" is strict.
There's an important strategic consideration for the timing of withdrawals relative to your residential status in India:
During RNOR phase (typically first 2-3 years after return): Your IRA withdrawals generally aren't taxable in India. This creates a valuable window to take distributions that are only subject to US tax. Many returning NRIs strategically withdraw larger amounts during RNOR status to minimize overall lifetime taxes.
After becoming ROR: Withdrawals are taxable in India, but you can claim Foreign Tax Credit for US taxes paid. The effective tax rate depends on both countries' rates and exchange rates.
Real Scenario: Tax Calculation Example
Let's walk through a complete example to see how taxes work in practice.
Meet Kavita: She's 62 years old, returned to India in 2023, and is now an ROR (FY 2025-26). She has a Traditional IRA worth $400,000 and decides to withdraw $60,000 to purchase an apartment in Bangalore.
US Taxation:
- Withdrawal amount: $60,000
- US withholding at 30%: $18,000
- Net received: $42,000
- After filing Form 1040-NR, actual US tax liability: $13,500 (assumes 22.5% effective rate)
- US refund due: $4,500
Indian Taxation:
- Withdrawal amount in INR: ₹49.8 lakhs (at ₹83/$)
- Assuming Kavita's total income places her in the 30% tax bracket
- Indian tax on IRA withdrawal: ₹14.94 lakhs
- Foreign Tax Credit for US tax paid: ₹11.21 lakhs ($13,500 × ₹83)
- Net Indian tax payable: ₹3.73 lakhs
- Total tax paid (US + India): ₹11.21 lakhs + ₹3.73 lakhs = ₹14.94 lakhs
- Effective total tax rate: 30%
Net amount after all taxes: $60,000 - $13,500 (US tax) - ₹3.73 lakhs (approximately $4,494) = approximately $42,006
The key insight here is that through proper use of the Foreign Tax Credit under DTAA, Kavita pays tax at essentially her Indian tax rate, avoiding true double taxation. However, she must file returns in both countries and claim the credit properly using Form 67 in India.
Compare this to a scenario where Kavita had withdrawn the same amount during her RNOR phase two years earlier. She would have paid only the US tax of $13,500, saving approximately $4,500 in Indian taxes. This illustrates why the timing of withdrawals relative to your residential status matters significantly.
How Do IRAs Compare to Indian Retirement Accounts?
When you're planning for retirement as an NRI, it's helpful to understand how US IRAs stack up against popular Indian retirement savings options. Each has distinct features, tax treatments, and suitability for different situations.
IRA vs NPS (National Pension System)
The National Pension System is India's market-linked pension scheme, and it shares some similarities with IRAs while having important differences.
Investment approach: Both allow market-linked investments. NPS offers a choice between equity (up to 75%), corporate bonds, and government securities. IRAs give you complete freedom to invest in stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and ETFs of your choice.
Contributions: NPS requires a minimum annual contribution of ₹6,000 to keep the account active. IRAs have higher limits ($7,000 or $8,000 if over 50) but no minimum requirement.
Tax treatment: NPS offers triple tax benefits in India - contributions are deductible under Section 80CCD(1) (up to ₹1.5 lakhs under Section 80C) plus an additional ₹50,000 under Section 80CCD(1B), growth is tax-deferred, and 60% of withdrawals at maturity are tax-free. Traditional IRAs offer tax deduction on contributions (in the US), tax-deferred growth, but full taxation on withdrawal.
Liquidity: NPS has strict withdrawal restrictions until age 60, and even then, you must use 40% to purchase an annuity. IRAs allow withdrawals anytime (though with penalties before 59½), offering more flexibility.
Returns: NPS has historically delivered 9-12% returns over long periods, depending on asset allocation. IRAs' returns depend entirely on your investment choices - the S&P 500 has averaged about 10% annually over the long term.
Who should choose what: If you're settled in India long-term, NPS offers excellent tax benefits within India's system and is designed specifically for Indian retirement. If you're working in the US or may return there, IRAs provide more flexibility and higher contribution limits.
IRA vs PPF (Public Provident Fund)
PPF is one of India's most popular small-savings schemes, offering guaranteed returns with complete safety.
Risk profile: PPF is completely risk-free, backed by the government, currently offering 7.1% interest. IRAs can range from conservative (bonds, stable value funds) to aggressive (equity-heavy portfolios), with returns varying accordingly.
Tax treatment: PPF has EEE (Exempt-Exempt-Exempt) status in India - contributions are deductible (up to ₹1.5 lakhs under Section 80C), interest is tax-free, and maturity proceeds are tax-free. This makes PPF very attractive for conservative Indian investors. IRAs offer tax benefits primarily in the US, with Traditional IRAs being EET (Exempt-Exempt-Taxed) and Roth IRAs being TEE (Taxed-Exempt-Exempt).
Lock-in period: PPF has a 15-year maturity period with partial withdrawal allowed after 5 years. IRAs have no mandatory lock-in, though early withdrawals incur penalties.
Contribution limits: PPF allows ₹500 to ₹1.5 lakh per year. IRAs allow up to $7,000-$8,000, which is significantly more at current exchange rates (approximately ₹5.8-₹6.6 lakhs).
Who should choose what: PPF is ideal if you're risk-averse, want guaranteed returns, and are focused on India-centric retirement planning. IRAs are better if you want higher growth potential, need flexibility, or have cross-border financial interests.
IRA vs EPF (Employee Provident Fund)
EPF is India's mandatory retirement savings scheme for salaried employees, similar in some ways to the US 401(k).
Mandatory vs voluntary: EPF contributions (12% of basic salary each from employee and employer) are mandatory for eligible employees in India. IRAs are voluntary, though you obviously need earned income to contribute.
Employer contribution: EPF's biggest advantage is the matching employer contribution, effectively doubling your savings. IRAs don't have employer matching (that's the domain of 401(k)s).
Interest rate: EPF currently offers 8.25% annual interest, which is guaranteed and typically higher than fixed-income investments in the US. IRA returns depend on investment choices.
Tax treatment: EPF is EEE in India if you complete five years of service. In the US, EPF withdrawals by NRIs may be taxable, creating complexity.
Portability: EPF can be transferred between Indian employers using your Universal Account Number (UAN). IRAs are completely portable across institutions and remain yours regardless of employment changes.
Who should choose what: If you're working in India, EPF is mandatory anyway and offers excellent benefits. If you're working in the US, maximize your 401(k) first (especially to get employer match), then contribute to an IRA if you have additional savings capacity.
Comparison Table: Returns, Tax Benefits, and Flexibility
| Feature | IRA (Traditional) | IRA (Roth) | NPS | PPF | EPF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Where Available | US | US | India | India | India |
| Expected Returns | 7 to 10 percent | 7 to 10 percent | 9 to 12 percent | 7.1 percent | 8.25 percent |
| Tax on Contribution (US) | Deductible | Not deductible | N A | N A | N A |
| Tax on Contribution (India) | No benefit | No benefit | Deductible | Deductible | Deductible |
| Tax on Growth (US) | Deferred | Tax free | N A | N A | N A |
| Tax on Growth (India) | Complex * | Complex * | Deferred | Tax free | Tax free |
| Tax on Withdrawal (US) | Fully taxed | Tax free ** | N A | N A | N A |
| Tax on Withdrawal (India) | Taxable for ROR | Potentially taxable *** | 60 percent tax free | Tax free | Tax free **** |
| Liquidity | High with penalties | High for contributions | Low | Medium | Medium |
| Employer Match | No | No | No | No | Yes |
| Minimum Contribution | None | None | ₹6000 per year | ₹500 per year | 12 percent of salary |
| Maximum Contribution | $7000 to $8000 | $7000 to $8000 | No limit | ₹1.5 lakh per year | Unlimited |
*Depends on RNOR vs ROR status, Section 89A filing, and DTAA treatment
**Qualified withdrawals only (age 59½+ and 5-year holding period)
***India may not recognize Roth IRA tax-free status
****If five years of service completed
The key takeaway is that these instruments serve different purposes and are optimized for different tax systems. Many financially savvy NRIs maintain retirement accounts in both countries, taking advantage of the benefits each system offers. The optimal mix depends on where you plan to retire, your tax situation in both countries, and your risk tolerance.
Critical Compliance Requirements for NRIs with IRAs
Managing an IRA while living in India requires careful attention to compliance in both countries. Filing the wrong forms or missing deadlines can result in excessive withholding, penalties, or even double taxation. Here are the critical forms you need to know about.
Form W-8BEN: Certifying Your Foreign Status
We touched on this earlier, but it's worth emphasizing how important Form W-8BEN is. This form certifies to your US financial institution that you're a foreign person (non-US resident) and establishes your eligibility for reduced withholding rates under the India-US tax treaty.
When to file: Submit Form W-8BEN to your IRA custodian when you first move to India and update your address. The form is valid for three years from the date you sign it.
Key information needed:
- Your name, permanent address in India, and mailing address
- Your US taxpayer identification number (TIN) if you have one, otherwise leave blank
- Your foreign tax identification number (for Indians, this is your PAN)
- Certification that you're a resident of India for tax purposes
- Treaty claim for reduced withholding (if applicable to your situation)
Important note: Form W-8BEN is submitted directly to your financial institution, not the IRS. Your broker keeps it on file to determine proper withholding on distributions.
Without a valid W-8BEN on file, your IRA custodian will apply the default 30% withholding rate on distributions, regardless of any treaty benefits you might be entitled to. Even if you can later claim a refund, this creates an unnecessary cash flow burden.
Form 10EE: Must-File for Returning NRIs
If you're an NRI returning to India with an IRA or 401(k), filing Form 10EE is one of the most important compliance steps you'll take. As discussed earlier, this form allows you to claim relief under Section 89A, aligning Indian taxation with US taxation of your retirement account.
When to file: Form 10EE must be filed electronically in the first year you become a Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR) in India. This election is irrevocable and applies to all future years.
Key information required:
- Personal details (name, PAN, address)
- Details of your specified retirement account (account number, institution, balance)
- Information on how income from the account is taxed in the US
- Documentation showing it's a recognized retirement account under US law
- Computation of income for previous years when you were NRI or RNOR
- Reconciliation statement of income
Consequences of not filing: If you don't file Form 10EE, India will tax the annual accrual (growth) in your IRA every year, even though you haven't withdrawn anything and the US hasn't taxed you yet. This creates severe double taxation and liquidity problems.
The form itself is somewhat technical, and many NRIs work with cross-border tax professionals to ensure it's completed correctly. The one-time effort of filing Form 10EE properly can save you tens of thousands of dollars over your lifetime.
Form 67: Claiming Foreign Tax Credit in India
When you withdraw from your IRA as an ROR in India, you'll pay US taxes on the distribution. To avoid double taxation, you need to claim a Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) in India using Form 67.
When to file: Form 67 is filed along with your Income Tax Return (ITR) in India for the year in which you received the IRA distribution and paid US taxes.
Key information needed:
- Details of foreign tax paid (amount, date, country)
- Proof of foreign tax payment (copy of US tax return, Form 1040-NR, and tax payment receipts)
- Details of income on which foreign tax was paid
- Relevant article of the tax treaty under which relief is being claimed
Exchange rate for conversion: The foreign tax paid must be converted to rupees using the State Bank of India's telegraphic transfer buying rate on the last day of the month immediately preceding the month in which the tax was paid.
Form 67 ensures you don't pay full tax in both countries on the same IRA distribution. The credit mechanism under DTAA means you effectively pay tax at the higher of the two countries' rates, not the sum of both rates.
Schedule FA and FSI: Reporting Foreign Assets in Indian ITR
If you're a Resident (whether RNOR or ROR) in India and have foreign assets like an IRA, you must report them in your Income Tax Return.
Schedule FA (Foreign Assets): This schedule requires you to provide details of all foreign assets, including:
- Bank accounts outside India
- Financial interest in any entity outside India
- Immovable property outside India
- Any other capital asset outside India (this includes your IRA)
- Signing authority in foreign accounts
For your IRA, you'll report:
- Country (United States)
- Name and address of the financial institution
- Account number
- Peak balance or value during the year
- Closing balance or value at year-end
Schedule FSI (Foreign Source Income): If you received any income from your IRA during the year (dividends, interest, capital gains, or distributions), you must report it in Schedule FSI, even if the income is not taxable in India due to RNOR status or DTAA provisions.
Penalties for non-reporting: Failure to report foreign assets can result in penalties up to ₹10 lakhs under Indian tax law. In recent years, India has significantly strengthened enforcement of foreign asset disclosure requirements.
The requirement to report doesn't automatically mean you owe tax in India. During your RNOR phase, your IRA income typically won't be taxable in India even though you must report it. Think of these schedules as disclosure requirements that help Indian tax authorities maintain transparency on foreign assets and income.
Proper compliance with all these forms creates a clear paper trail showing you've reported your IRA in both countries, paid taxes where due, and claimed appropriate treaty benefits. This documentation becomes especially valuable if either tax authority ever questions your filings.
Common Mistakes NRIs Make with IRAs (and How to Avoid Them)
Even financially sophisticated NRIs often stumble when it comes to managing IRAs across borders. Here are the most common and costly mistakes, along with strategies to avoid them.
Mistake 1: Contributing Without Eligible Income
Many NRIs don't realize that using the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE) to exclude all their income makes them ineligible for IRA contributions. They continue contributing to their IRA while living abroad, only to discover years later that these were excess contributions.
The consequence: Excess contributions are subject to a 6% penalty tax each year they remain in the account. If you made $7,000 in excess contributions and it took you three years to discover the mistake, you'd owe $1,260 in penalties ($7,000 × 6% × 3 years), plus you'd need to withdraw the excess.
How to avoid it: Before making any IRA contribution while living abroad, calculate your eligible income after FEIE. If you've excluded all your income, consider using the Foreign Tax Credit instead, which doesn't reduce your earned income for IRA purposes. Alternatively, if you have any US-sourced income (rental income from a US property, for instance), that counts toward your earned income for IRA contribution eligibility, though you can only contribute up to your total earned income.
Mistake 2: Not Filing Form 10EE When Becoming ROR
This is perhaps the single most expensive mistake returning NRIs make. Many NRIs simply aren't aware that Section 89A relief exists or that they need to file Form 10EE to claim it.
The consequence: Without Form 10EE, your IRA growth gets taxed annually in India based on accrual, even though you haven't withdrawn anything. Meanwhile, the US taxes you only upon withdrawal. This creates horrific double taxation scenarios.
For example, if your IRA grows by $50,000 in a year and you're an ROR without having filed Form 10EE, you could owe approximately ₹12.45 lakhs in Indian taxes on growth you haven't accessed. When you eventually withdraw years later, the US will tax the same growth again.
How to avoid it: Mark your calendar for the first year you'll become an ROR (usually your third year after returning to India for most people). Engage a cross-border tax advisor well before this transition to ensure Form 10EE is filed timely and correctly. Remember, this election is irrevocable and must be made in the first ROR year, you can't file it retroactively for a previous year.
Mistake 3: Withdrawing During RNOR Phase Without Strategy
While RNOR status creates a valuable window for tax-efficient IRA withdrawals (since you're not taxed in India on foreign income), some NRIs withdraw too much or too little without considering their overall financial picture.
Withdrawing too much: Taking huge lump sums just because they're "India tax-free" can push you into high US tax brackets and trigger unexpected US tax liabilities. Plus, you lose the benefit of continued tax-deferred growth on those funds.
Withdrawing too little: Some NRIs keep their entire IRA untouched during RNOR status, then face full taxation in both countries once they become ROR. They miss the golden window when withdrawals face only US taxation.
How to avoid it: Create a strategic withdrawal plan before your RNOR phase begins. Consider factors like:
- Your immediate cash needs (home purchase, children's education, business investment)
- Your age (are you close to penalty-free withdrawal at 59½?)
- US tax brackets (withdrawing enough to fill up lower brackets without jumping to higher ones)
- Your expected tax situation after becoming ROR
Many tax advisors recommend moderate strategic withdrawals during RNOR years rather than either extreme. For instance, if you're 60 years old, an RNOR, and have a $500,000 IRA, you might withdraw $30,000-$40,000 annually during your 2-3 year RNOR window. This provides liquidity, takes advantage of India tax-free status, avoids high US brackets, and still leaves substantial funds growing for later.
Other common mistakes to watch for:
Not maintaining proper documentation: Keep copies of all US tax returns, Forms 1040-NR, proof of tax payments, Form W-8BEN, and IRA statements. You'll need these to claim Foreign Tax Credit in India and to prove your compliance history if questioned by either tax authority.
Forgetting about estate tax implications: US estate tax can apply to significant US assets held by non-residents. While there's currently a $60,000 exemption for non-residents (much lower than the $13.61 million exemption for US citizens in 2025), large IRA balances combined with other US assets could trigger estate tax issues. This is particularly important for succession planning if you have heirs in India.
Assuming Roth IRA is always tax-free in India: While Roth IRA withdrawals are tax-free in the US, India's tax authorities may not recognize this special status. Some interpretations suggest that Roth IRA earnings could be taxable in India even if they're tax-free in the US. This ambiguity makes Traditional IRAs potentially less complicated for NRIs planning to return to India, despite Roth IRAs' apparent tax advantages.
Cashing out too early due to confusion: Some NRIs panic when they move back to India and immediately cash out their IRA, triggering unnecessary penalties and taxes. Remember, you're not required to close your IRA when leaving the US. Take time to understand your options and make an informed decision rather than a rushed one.
Should You Roll Over Your 401(k) to an IRA as an NRI?
Many NRIs have both 401(k) accounts (from current or former employers) and IRAs. When you leave your US employer, whether to change jobs or return to India, you face a decision: keep your 401(k) with your former employer, roll it over to an IRA, or withdraw it. This decision has significant implications for NRIs.
Benefits of IRA Rollover vs Keeping 401(k)
Investment flexibility: IRAs typically offer far more investment options than 401(k) plans. Most 401(k)s limit you to 10-30 mutual fund options selected by your employer. With an IRA, you can invest in virtually any stock, bond, mutual fund, ETF, or other securities. For NRIs managing accounts from India, this flexibility can be valuable for adjusting your portfolio over time.
Lower fees: Many 401(k) plans, especially those from smaller employers, charge higher administrative fees than what you'd pay with a low-cost IRA at Vanguard, Fidelity, or Schwab. Over decades, even a 0.5% difference in annual fees can cost you tens of thousands of dollars.
Easier to manage from abroad: Maintaining contact with a former US employer from India can be challenging. What happens if your employer changes plan administrators, merges with another company, or goes out of business? An IRA at a major brokerage is simpler to manage internationally.
Roth conversion opportunity: When you roll over a Traditional 401(k) to a Traditional IRA, you have the option to later convert it to a Roth IRA. You'll pay taxes on the conversion, but if you're in a lower tax bracket during your RNOR years in India, this could be an opportune time to convert while facing only US taxes.
Consolidation: If you've worked at multiple US companies, you might have several 401(k) accounts scattered across different employers. Rolling them all into a single IRA simplifies your financial life and makes it easier to implement a cohesive investment strategy.
However, there are some reasons to keep your 401(k):
Creditor protection: In some US states, 401(k) assets have stronger protection from creditors and lawsuits than IRA assets. This varies by state and may be irrelevant if you're living in India, but it's worth considering.
Earlier penalty-free access: If you leave your employer in or after the year you turn 55, you can take 401(k) withdrawals without the 10% early withdrawal penalty. With an IRA, you must wait until 59½ (with few exceptions).
Loan options: Some 401(k) plans allow loans against your balance, which IRAs don't permit. However, taking 401(k) loans when you're no longer employed with that company is typically not allowed anyway.
Lower cost investments: Some large employers negotiate institutional-class mutual funds for their 401(k) plans with expense ratios even lower than what individual investors can access. If you're fortunate enough to have such a plan, this benefit is worth preserving.
Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA Rollover Considerations
When rolling over a 401(k), you have options regarding the destination account.
Traditional 401(k) to Traditional IRA: This is a straightforward rollover with no immediate tax consequences. Your money moves from one tax-deferred account to another. This makes sense if you want to preserve the tax-deferred status and don't want to pay taxes now.
Traditional 401(k) to Roth IRA: This is called a Roth conversion, and it's a taxable event. The entire rollover amount is added to your taxable income in the year of conversion, and you'll pay taxes at your marginal rate.
For NRIs, the timing of a Roth conversion matters significantly:
During RNOR status: Converting while you're RNOR means you pay US taxes but potentially no Indian taxes on the conversion amount (since foreign income generally isn't taxable during RNOR). This can be an attractive window for conversions.
After becoming ROR: Converting after you're ROR means the conversion amount is taxable in both countries (though you can claim Foreign Tax Credit under DTAA). This is less attractive unless you're in a particularly low US tax year.
However, remember the caveat we discussed earlier: India may not fully recognize Roth IRA's tax-free status on withdrawals. Before doing a Roth conversion specifically as an NRI planning to live in India, consult with a cross-border tax advisor to understand the implications.
Roth 401(k) to Roth IRA: If your employer offered a Roth 401(k) and you contributed to it, you can roll this over to a Roth IRA tax-free. This preserves the Roth nature of the account. One key benefit is that Roth IRAs don't have Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) during your lifetime, while Roth 401(k)s do.
Decision Framework for NRIs
Here's a practical framework for deciding whether to roll over your 401(k) to an IRA when you're an NRI:
Consider rolling over to IRA if:
- You've left your US employer and are unlikely to return to that company
- Your 401(k) has limited investment options or high fees
- You want easier account management from India
- You have multiple 401(k)s and want to consolidate
- You want the flexibility to do strategic Roth conversions
- Your former employer's plan doesn't allow international participants
Consider keeping your 401(k) if:
- You have excellent, low-cost investment options in your current plan
- You're between 55 and 59½ and might need penalty-free access
- Your account balance is large and you value the potentially stronger creditor protection
- You plan to return to the US and possibly rejoin your employer
- You haven't yet updated your documents and want time to make an informed decision
The timing question: You don't have to decide immediately when you leave your employer. Most 401(k) plans allow you to keep your account indefinitely as long as your balance exceeds $5,000. Take time to research your options, understand the tax implications given your specific situation, and make an informed choice.
Many NRIs in their RNOR phase find that rolling over to an IRA during this period gives them more control and potentially better tax planning opportunities as they transition to permanent life in India. The combination of IRA flexibility and RNOR tax advantages can be powerful when used strategically.
Planning Your IRA Strategy: Practical Scenarios
Let's bring everything together by looking at three common scenarios NRIs face with their IRAs. These examples will help you see how the concepts we've discussed apply to real situations.
Scenario 1: NRI Planning to Retire in the US
Meet Arjun: He's 45, working in Silicon Valley on an H-1B visa, and plans to obtain his green card and eventually US citizenship. He intends to retire in the US at age 65.
IRA strategy for Arjun:
Arjun should maximize his IRA contributions every year, focusing on Roth IRA if his income permits (2025 Roth IRA income limits are $146,000 for single filers and $230,000 for married filing jointly). Since he plans to retire in the US, he'll benefit fully from Roth IRA's tax-free qualified withdrawals without the complications of Indian taxation.
He should prioritize his employer's 401(k) first, at least up to the employer match, then max out his IRA, then contribute additional amounts back to the 401(k) if he has remaining savings capacity.
Since Arjun is working in the US with US earned income, he has no complications with contribution eligibility. He should set up automatic contributions to take advantage of dollar-cost averaging and ensure he consistently saves $7,000 ($8,000 once he turns 50) annually.
For asset allocation, Arjun can be fairly aggressive given his 20-year timeline to retirement. A portfolio of 80-90% stocks and 10-20% bonds could be appropriate, with gradual rebalancing toward more conservative allocations as he approaches retirement.
Key action items for Arjun:
- Maximize Roth IRA contributions if eligible (Roth conversions if over income limits using backdoor Roth strategy)
- Consider tax loss harvesting in his taxable accounts to offset gains
- Review and rebalance his portfolio annually
- Keep excellent records of all contributions and conversions for future tax planning
Scenario 2: NRI Returning to India Within 5 Years
Meet Priya: She's 52, has worked in the US for 8 years, and plans to return to India in 2028 when her children finish college. She has a Traditional IRA worth $180,000.
IRA strategy for Priya:
Priya's situation requires more nuanced planning because she's bridging two tax systems and will be in her RNOR phase when she first returns.
Before leaving the US (2025-2027): Priya should continue contributing to her IRA while she has earned income. Given she's over 50, she can contribute $8,000 annually. She should avoid taking early withdrawals (before 59½) to escape the 10% penalty.
Upon returning to India (2028): Priya needs to immediately:
- Update her address with her IRA custodian
- File Form W-8BEN certifying her foreign status
- Understand her residential status (likely RNOR for the first 2-3 years)
During RNOR phase (2028-2030): This is Priya's golden window. She'll turn 59½ in 2030, eliminating the early withdrawal penalty. During her RNOR years, she should consider strategic withdrawals that face only US taxation (not Indian taxation).
For example, she might withdraw $35,000-$40,000 annually during these years, staying within lower US tax brackets (assuming she has no other significant US income). These withdrawals provide liquidity for settling in India while taking advantage of RNOR tax status.
When becoming ROR (2031 onwards): Priya must file Form 10EE in her first year as ROR to elect Section 89A relief. This prevents India from taxing the annual growth in her remaining IRA balance.
Any withdrawals after becoming ROR will be taxed in both countries, but she can claim Foreign Tax Credit in India using Form 67 to avoid double taxation.
Key action items for Priya:
- Maximize IRA contributions before leaving US ($8,000 × 3 years = $24,000)
- Create a withdrawal strategy for RNOR years
- Mark calendar for ROR transition and Form 10EE filing
- Consult a cross-border tax advisor to model different withdrawal scenarios
- Keep detailed records of all IRA activity for claiming Foreign Tax Credit later
Scenario 3: NRI Already Back in India with Existing IRA
Meet Vikram: He's 38, returned to India in 2022 after 10 years in the US, currently holds RNOR status, and has a Traditional IRA worth $225,000. He hasn't touched it since returning and isn't sure what to do.
IRA strategy for Vikram:
Vikram's situation represents a common pattern where NRIs return to India and "park" their IRA without a clear strategy.
Immediate assessment (2025): Vikram needs to determine:
- His current residential status (still RNOR or transitioned to ROR?)
- Whether he filed Form 10EE if he's already ROR
- His IRA custodian's policies for non-resident account holders
- Whether Form W-8BEN is on file
Based on when Vikram returned (2022), he likely became ROR in FY 2024-25. If he didn't file Form 10EE at that time, he faces a serious problem: India has been taxing his IRA growth annually since then, while that growth sits untouched in his account.
If Form 10EE was not filed: Vikram should immediately consult a tax professional to assess his exposure and potentially file revised returns if necessary. Unfortunately, Form 10EE cannot be filed retroactively if the first ROR year has passed, which means he may face continued annual taxation on accrued growth. This makes early withdrawals more attractive to avoid compounding taxation issues.
If Form 10EE was properly filed: Vikram has more flexibility. At age 38, he has 21+ years before retirement. He needs to decide whether to:
Option A - Leave it to grow: Keep the full $225,000 invested for long-term growth. At a 7% average annual return, this could grow to over $900,000 by age 60. Withdrawals after age 59½ will face taxation in both countries (with Foreign Tax Credit offsetting some Indian tax).
Option B - Strategic withdrawals now: Take some distributions while relatively young to meet current financial goals in India (business investment, home purchase, children's education planning). The 10% US early withdrawal penalty applies, making each $100,000 withdrawal net only about $70,000 after US taxes and penalties.
Option C - Hybrid approach: Keep most of the IRA invested for long-term growth but take limited strategic withdrawals for specific high-priority needs. This balances long-term growth with current liquidity needs.
Given Vikram's age (21 years from penalty-free withdrawals), Option A likely makes most sense unless he has pressing financial needs that warrant incurring the early withdrawal penalty.
Key action items for Vikram:
- Verify Form 10EE filing status immediately
- File Form W-8BEN with IRA custodian if not already done
- Rebalance IRA portfolio appropriate for 20+ year horizon
- Create financial plan for Indian financial goals separate from IRA
- Set calendar reminder for age 59½ to reassess withdrawal strategy
- Review annually and adjust as needed
These three scenarios illustrate how different circumstances require different IRA strategies. The optimal approach depends on your age, planned retirement location, residential status in India, timeline to retirement, and financial goals in both countries.
There's no one-size-fits-all answer, which is why understanding the underlying rules and tax implications is so important for making informed decisions.
Conclusion
Managing an IRA as an NRI requires navigating two complex tax systems, but with proper planning, you can maximize your retirement savings while avoiding costly mistakes. Here are your key action steps:
If you're currently working in the US: Maximize your IRA contributions while you have earned income. Choose between Traditional and Roth based on your expected retirement location and tax situation. Keep excellent records of all contributions.
If you're planning to return to India: Understand your residential status timeline (RNOR vs ROR). File Form W-8BEN with your IRA custodian when you move. Consider strategic withdrawals during your RNOR phase when distributions face only US taxation.
If you've already returned to India: Verify that Form 10EE was filed in your first year as ROR. If not filed, consult a cross-border tax advisor immediately to assess your situation. Plan withdrawals to minimize lifetime tax burden using DTAA Foreign Tax Credit provisions.
Above all, remember that IRAs remain a powerful retirement savings tool even when you're living outside the US. Don't make rushed decisions out of confusion or fear. Take time to understand your options, and consult with professionals who specialize in cross-border taxation for NRIs.
Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial or tax advice. Tax laws vary by individual circumstances and are subject to change. Consult qualified cross-border tax professionals for advice specific to your situation, as IRA taxation for NRIs involves complex interactions between US and Indian tax codes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I contribute to an IRA from India after becoming an NRI?
No, you generally cannot contribute to an IRA once you've moved to India and have no US earned income. To contribute to an IRA, you must have US taxable compensation (earned income). If you're using the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE) to exclude all your foreign income, you'll have zero eligible income for IRA contributions. However, if you use the Foreign Tax Credit instead or have income remaining after FEIE, you can still contribute. Once you're settled in India with no US employment, you cannot make new contributions, but you can maintain your existing IRA indefinitely.
What happens to my IRA if I move to India?
Your IRA remains yours when you move to India. You're not required to close it or withdraw funds. You need to update your address with your IRA custodian and file Form W-8BEN to certify your non-resident status. Your investments continue to grow tax-deferred (Traditional IRA) or tax-free (Roth IRA) in the US. The main changes are that you cannot make new contributions without US earned income, and you must report the account in your Indian tax returns (Schedule FA). During your RNOR phase (typically first 2-3 years after return), withdrawals face only US taxation. Once you become ROR, withdrawals are taxed in both countries, but you can claim Foreign Tax Credit under DTAA to avoid double taxation.
How is my IRA taxed in India when I withdraw?
IRA taxation in India depends on your residential status. If you're RNOR (Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident), IRA withdrawals are generally not taxable in India as they're considered foreign income. Once you become ROR (Resident and Ordinarily Resident), withdrawals are fully taxable in India as part of your global income. However, you can claim Foreign Tax Credit using Form 67 for US taxes already paid, preventing double taxation under the India-US DTAA. For Traditional IRAs, the entire withdrawal is taxable. For Roth IRAs, while withdrawals are tax-free in the US, India may not recognize this status and could tax the earnings portion. File Form 10EE in your first year as ROR to defer taxation on annual IRA growth under Section 89A.
What is the equivalent of an IRA in India?
India doesn't have an exact equivalent to IRAs, but the closest alternatives are NPS (National Pension System), PPF (Public Provident Fund), and EPF (Employee Provident Fund). NPS is most similar, offering market-linked returns with equity exposure up to 75%, tax-deferred growth, and partial tax-free withdrawals at maturity. PPF provides guaranteed returns (currently 7.1%) with complete tax exemption (EEE status). EPF is mandatory for salaried employees with employer matching and 8.25% interest. Unlike IRAs, these Indian schemes have lower contribution limits (NPS minimum ₹6,000/year, PPF max ₹1.5 lakh/year) but offer India-specific tax benefits. For NRIs planning to retire in India, combining an existing US IRA with Indian retirement accounts can provide diversification across tax systems.
How do NRIs avoid double taxation on IRA withdrawals?
NRIs avoid double taxation through the India-US Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) by claiming Foreign Tax Credit. Here's how it works: First, the US withholds tax (typically 30%) when you withdraw from your IRA. You file Form 1040-NR to determine your actual US tax liability and potentially get a refund. In India, you report the same withdrawal in your ITR and calculate Indian tax due. Then you file Form 67 along with your ITR to claim credit for US taxes already paid. The Foreign Tax Credit reduces your Indian tax liability by the amount of US tax paid (converted to rupees at SBI TT buying rate). You effectively pay tax at the higher of the two countries' rates, not the sum of both. Additionally, file Form 10EE in your first year as ROR to claim Section 89A relief, which defers taxation on annual IRA growth until withdrawal, preventing taxation timing mismatches between the two countries.
About the Author
By Prakash
CEO & Founder of InvestMates
Prakash is the CEO & Founder of InvestMates, a digital wealth management platform built for the global Indian community. With leadership experience at Microsoft, HCL, and Accenture across multiple countries, he witnessed firsthand challenges of managing cross-border wealth. Drawing from his expertise in engineering, product management, and business leadership, Prakash founded InvestMates to democratize financial planning and make professional wealth management accessible, affordable, and transparent for every global Indian.